GhanaWebNews
  • Home
    • About Ghana >
      • Slave Trade a true History
      • Kwame Nkrumah centenary >
        • John Dramani Mahama - Open Mailbox
        • Atta Mills - Open Mailbox
        • Atta Mills - Open Mailbox Page 2
      • People of Ghana
      • Supreme Court of Ghana
      • Flag of Ghana
      • Ghana Highlife and Overview
      • Anthem and Pledge >
        • Bojo Beach Resort
        • KOKROBITE Beach Resort
        • Ghana at Work
        • Ghana Video News
        • Ghana Live Radio
  • Ghana Music
  • Online Shop
  • Ghana Elections 2020
  • Ghana News
    • Ghana Elections 2020 Updates
    • Charles Abugre >
      • About Charles Abugre
    • Accra Airport - Welcome Atta Mills
    • Top Pages September 11, 2015
    • Top Pages September 4, 2015
  • Ghana News Archive
    • GhanaWeb News Special
  • Fun and Education
    • Ask John Mahama
  • Accra Airport
    • Kotoka
    • Tamale International Airport
    • Kumasi International Airport
    • Sunyani Airport
    • ECOWAS
  • World Newspaper Headlines
    • Newspaper Headlines - Africa
    • Newspaper Headlines - USA
    • Newspaper Headlines - Canada
  • Terms, Conditions & Privacy Policy
    • About >
      • Contact
  • Ghana Photos
  • Home
    • About Ghana >
      • Slave Trade a true History
      • Kwame Nkrumah centenary >
        • John Dramani Mahama - Open Mailbox
        • Atta Mills - Open Mailbox
        • Atta Mills - Open Mailbox Page 2
      • People of Ghana
      • Supreme Court of Ghana
      • Flag of Ghana
      • Ghana Highlife and Overview
      • Anthem and Pledge >
        • Bojo Beach Resort
        • KOKROBITE Beach Resort
        • Ghana at Work
        • Ghana Video News
        • Ghana Live Radio
  • Ghana Music
  • Online Shop
  • Ghana Elections 2020
  • Ghana News
    • Ghana Elections 2020 Updates
    • Charles Abugre >
      • About Charles Abugre
    • Accra Airport - Welcome Atta Mills
    • Top Pages September 11, 2015
    • Top Pages September 4, 2015
  • Ghana News Archive
    • GhanaWeb News Special
  • Fun and Education
    • Ask John Mahama
  • Accra Airport
    • Kotoka
    • Tamale International Airport
    • Kumasi International Airport
    • Sunyani Airport
    • ECOWAS
  • World Newspaper Headlines
    • Newspaper Headlines - Africa
    • Newspaper Headlines - USA
    • Newspaper Headlines - Canada
  • Terms, Conditions & Privacy Policy
    • About >
      • Contact
  • Ghana Photos
GhanaWebNews

Gbewaa judgment debt: Betty Mould, Ben Kumbour indicted

7/1/2015

Comments

 
Source: citifmonline.com  -  The judgment debt commission has indicted two former attorney generals- Betty Mould Idrissu and the Dr. Benjamin Kumbour- in the varied roles they played that led to the payment of huge sums of money to the Gbewaa Civil Engineering Company and its Managing Director Yakubu Adam Kasule.
A leaked report from the Sole Commissioner of the Judgment Debt Commission stated that “the premises of the then Attorney-General Betty Mould-Iddisu’s letter dated 29th October, 2010 to the Minister of Finance to the effect that all the four suits she settled were mounted by Gbewaa Civil Engineering Ltd against the Government of Ghana (GoG) was far from the truth.”

This was because “one of the suits was initiated by the Government of Ghana (GoG) against Mr. Yakubu Kasule and his company. The subject of that suit was that Gbewaa Civil Engineering Ltd had obtained payment for spare parts supplied to the Government of Ghana by KOLON (UK) LTD based on misrepresentations made by the defendant company and that the defendant company was not entitled to the said payments. The determination of that case was scuttled by the settlement.”

The report further stated that “her (Betty Mould Iddrissu) contention that all the suits had spanned a period of fifteen (15) years was not correct.”

This, according to the commission, was because “all the cases mounted by Gbewaa Civil Engineering Ltd and its Managing Director Mr. Yakubu Adam Kasule against the Attorney-General & Others, were filed in 2010 as suggested by their suit numbers. It was therefore not correct, as the then Attorney-General stated that, the suits had spanned a period of fifteen (15) years.”

The Commission also insisted that the settlement brokered by Betty Mould-Iddrisu, “notwithstanding the good intentions she might have had at the time she took over as the Attorney-General of Ghana, did not follow due process”.

And exonerated Mr. Martin Amidu insisting he “did not therefore err when he requested for answers from the Solicitor-General on the purported settlement before going ahead to advise the Minister of Finance to pay the sum agreed on at the settlement table.”

The report further affirmed former attorney general Martin Amidu’s decision to contend an order of settlement issued by his predecessor Betty Mould Iddrissu saying that “the State had appealed against the acquittal of Mr. Yakubu Kasule on the basis of the Nolle Prosequi (NP) entered by the Attorney-General against his prosecution with the other accused persons. The entry of the NP did not mean that the State had curtailed the prosecution of Mr. Yakubu Kasule”. To the commission the trial Court, therefore, could only have discharged him but not to acquit”. Since what was meant by his acquittal was that the Attorney-General could not re-arraign Mr. Yakubu Kasule before court on the same charges.

The commission further accused former Attoney General and now minister of defense Dr. Benjamin Kumbour of seeking clearance for the payment of the said amounts to the plaintiff even when he had dragged the matter to court for stay of execution of an earlier order.

This to them is because though “(Dr.) Benjamin Kumbuor, did appeal against the decision of S. K. A. Asiedu, J. Notwithstanding the pendency of the appeal, the new A-G went ahead to accept the amounts entered in the Certificate of Judgment by Mr. Yakubu Adam Kasule as monies owed by the State to Gbewaa Engineering Ltd and its Managing Director”.

This is regardless of the fact that Dr. Kumbour justified his actions by stating that “he did that as a necessity to release the hold on vital GoG accounts.”

The commission further questioned the figures that Dr. Kumbour ordered to be paid as settlement debt agreed on by the former Attorney-General Betty Mould-Iddrisu when Dr. Kunbuor took over as Attorney-General from Mr. Martin Amidu, granted the Executive had agreed to make good the judgment of S.K.A. Asiedu, J.

“In the settlement brokered by Mrs. Betty Mould-Iddrisu, the sums agreed on to be paid to Mr. Kasule and his lawyer were; US$5, 000,000.00 and GHc1, 000,000.00 respectively. Mr. Kasule went to court to claim these sums with interest at a time when the new Attorney-General Hon. Mr. Martin Amidu was questioning the legal basis of the said settlement as the substantive Attorney-General. The court, presided over by S.K.A. Asiedu, J, granted Mr. Kasule’s claim and awarded him damages of GHc150, 000.00 for breach of contract and costs of GHc35, 000.00.”

And further stated that “in the second alleged settlement by Dr. Kunbuor, these figures jumped to US$6, 272,514.41 and GHc1, 630,380.04 respectively. The excess alone for the dollar amount is US$1, 272,514.41 (which is more than twenty-five percent increment) and that for the cedi is GHc630, 380.04 (which is over sixty-three percent increment). Could the additions be interest only? If yes, then how were the interests calculated? What rates were used to calculate both the cedi and the dollar interest?”

To them “Since what was agreed on as the final amount to be paid to plaintiff/judgment-creditor at the settlement with Mrs. Betty Mould-Iddrisu had no interest component attached to it, any interest chargeable that the plaintiffs/j-creditors could have asked for or demanded should have been based on the provisions of C.I. 52 of 2005, particularly Rule 1 (1) and in respect of the Post-Judgment Interest, Rule 1 (2). This should have been the prevailing commercial lending rate calculated on a simple interest basis.”

The commission believes that Dr. Kunbour should have still pursued the case regardless of the garnishee order from the plaintiffs since to them “The fact that Mr. Yakubu Kasule had obtained a garnishee order against the State was not a valid ground to abandon the appeal”.

Recommendations



    The commission is of the view that the A-G should have proceeded further to the Court of Appeal for a Post-Mortem Examination to be conducted on that judgment. It is, however, regrettable that the Executive was convinced or cajoled to succumb to the pressures of Mr. Yakubu Adam Kasule on the false assumption that with the garnishee order absolute decreed by the trial Court, everything was lost. 

  1. The Commission recommends strongly that the A-G should always take pains to dissect cases against the State properly and fight to the end instead of easily throwing in the towel with the least pressure when the fight could be won at the end of the last round.


  2. It further heaped praises Martin saying that he has been vilified for being just. “He has suffered several media bashing propelled by some faceless people, for pursuing a just course as a patriotic citizen of Ghana and a good one of course. This Commission is amazed that he remains unfazed by such wrong attacks. The Commission accordingly accords him the enviable esteem of a Ghanaian who loves his country more than himself”.


Background

The 1st Plaintiff, Gbewaa Civil Engineering Company, which is a limited liability company with the 2nd Plaintiff as its Managing Director, took a writ of summons against the Attorney-General claiming the following reliefs:

  1. An order to compel the defendant and the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning forthwith to pay plaintiffs an amount of; (i) Five Million United States Dollars (US$5m), (ii) One Million Ghana cedis (GHc1m)


  2. Interest on the said amounts from the 29th day of October, 2010 till the date of final payment


  3. General damages


  4. Costs


The defendant contested the matter and filed a counter-claim as follows:

  1. A declaration that the settlement agreement reached with the 1st plaintiff was void for being contrary to public policy, was entered into under mistaken apprehension of facts; lacked the relevant consent, and is consequently unenforceable,


  2. An order setting aside the purported settlement agreement between the 1st plaintiff and the defendant on grounds of public policy, mistake and for lack of consent of the other defendants to the several actions between plaintiffs and defendant.


On the 1st day of June 2012, the High Court, Accra, coram S.K.A. Asiedu, J, entered judgment in favour of the plaintiffs on all the reliefs. The Court awarded plaintiffs general damages of GHc150, 000.00 for breach of contract and a further GHc35, 000.00 as costs.
Comments
    Ghana Elections 2020

    Categories

    All
    Africa News
    Airline News
    Better Ghana
    Chieftaincy
    Crime In Ghana
    Diasporia
    Doctors Strike
    Education
    Elections 2016
    Food-warning
    General News
    Ghana Election 2020
    Ghana Flood 2015
    Ghana Writers
    Health News
    Proudly Ghana Produced
    Public Agenda Ghana
    Region Accra
    Region Ashanti
    Region Brong Ahafo
    Region Brong-Ahafo
    Region Central
    Region Eastern
    Region-northern
    Regions Of Ghana
    Region Upper East
    Region Upper West
    Region Volta
    Region Western
    Religion
    Rights In Ghana
    Special Extra
    Sport
    Taking Ghana For A RIDE
    Travel Advise
    World News

    More GhanaWeb News 
    LATEST Read Here
    • Newspaper Headlines - Africa
    Ghana Live Radio, Radio Ghana, Listen to Ghana Radio, Ghana Radio, Live Radio, Ghanaweb Radio,
    Weeding photo, Photographer in Ghana, African Wedding, News photographer, Event Photographer, Weddin Ghana, Ghana weddings,

    Home Page

    News Archives

    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    October 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    April 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014
    October 2013

    More Archive News - starting from Sep 17, 2015
    Ghana News Archive
    Ghanaians used as Ebola TEST-PIGS, for Multi-Western Pharma interests!  WARNING !!!
    Picture
    Follow @GhanaNet
    Do you know, the weekday... you where born?  Find out, with our easy calculator!
    Crime in Ghana - Ghana Police News, Ghana Police, Security in Ghana, latest police news,
    Crime in Ghana - News
    1. Supreme Court of Ghana.
    2. Adomi Bridge at Atimpoku
    3. Photo Report:  Ghana at Work
    4. Photo Report: The People of Ghana
    5. Kotoka International Airport -Info`s and Pictures
    6. Tamale International Airport (N/Region)
    7. Older Ghana News 
    8. Charity Ghana-Net​
    9. Advertise FREE: Ghana Real Estates - Sell or Buy. Rent. Offer your services! FREE Ads!
    10. National Museum
    Did you know? 
    Marburg virus and Ebola virus are the SAME..! Read Here!
    Airborne Ebola is "Solution to Earth's Overpopulation Problem.... > More <
    IMF, USA set to ruin Ghana - former British Ambassador

    RSS Feed

    GhanaMirror com, Ghanaweb, Ghana News, Latest, Ghana News Online.  Weekly Updates,  GhanaWebNews
    GhanaWeb-News.com
    GhanaMirror.com
    GhanaMirror.uk

News Websites

  1. Chronicle
  2. Daily Graphic
  3. Daily Guide
  4. District News
  5. Ghana News Agency
  6. Ghanaian Times
  7. Ghana Review
  8. Government News
  9. Joy Online
  10. Peace FM
  11. Radio XYZ
  12. The Statesman
  13. Gye Nyame Concord
  14. Obaasema magazine ​

Connected

  • ghana0.com
  • ghana-net.com
  • NigerianRadio.com​
  • GhanaHotels.biz​
  • GhanaMirror.com
  • ​KenyaWebNews.com

  • Therms & Conditions / Privacy / Contact
  • GhanaMirror.com News Site-Map (Bing)
Ghana Radio Live